The Iron Lung and the Polio Survivor Movement

Polio respiratory survivors built some of the founding institutions of disability rights. They ran peer newsletters that became international networks, won the attendant-care fight that made independent living possible, identified post-polio syndrome before medicine did, and insisted on living in dormitories and apartments rather than hospitals. This page tells that story first, because it is the more important one, and then tells the harder story of who controlled the machine they depended on.

Why This Matters

The iron lung is usually remembered as a museum object from a solved problem. That framing erases the people who lived in one, many of whom were still alive and organizing well into this century, and it obscures a pattern that did not end with polio: life-sustaining equipment can be withdrawn by manufacturers and payers while the people who depend on it are still breathing.

The polio survivor community’s own awareness slogan, used by Post-Polio Health International since 2007, is a direct answer to the idea that polio is a closed chapter: “WE’RE STILL HERE!”

Quick Overview

Before 1928, respiratory paralysis was almost always fatal. The iron lung created a population of long-term survivors that had not previously existed.
Access was rationed from the start by cost, geography, and race. Warm Springs admitted only white patients; the segregated South offered Black children a single small center at Tuskegee.
Control sat with physicians, hospitals, charities, and manufacturers, not with users.
Polio survivors founded core institutions of independent living, including the network that became Post-Polio Health International and the first Center for Independent Living.
Manufacturers stopped making parts and insurers stopped funding repairs while people were still using the machines. The last users survived on scavenged parts and volunteer machinists.

A Note on Language

Disability style guides and disabled-led sources reject “polio victim,” “afflicted with,” “suffers from,” and “confined to” an iron lung or a wheelchair. The National Center on Disability and Journalism instructs against “polio victim.” The University of Kansas guide notes that “survivor” recognizes a person’s ability to grow and change, and that people use a wheelchair rather than being confined to one.

There is real disagreement inside the community. The disability historian and polio survivor Hugh Gregory Gallagher preferred the plain noun “a polio” and was wary of both “victim” and “survivor.” This page uses “polio survivor” and “iron lung user.”

The device itself has several names: iron lung (the popular and community-adopted term), tank respirator (clinical), and negative-pressure ventilator (current technical usage, contrasted with the positive-pressure ventilation that replaced it).

What Polio Survivors Built

Gini Laurie and the Peer Network

Gini Laurie (1913–1989) is often called the grandmother of the independent living movement, a community honorific rather than an uncontested title. Volunteering at the Toomey Pavilion respiratory center in Cleveland, she co-edited a mimeographed peer newsletter, the Toomeyville Jr. Gazette, written by and for polio survivors, sharing practical information about equipment and life at home.

That newsletter grew into an international institution. Incorporated in 1960 as Iron Lung Polio Assistance, Inc., it became the Rehabilitation Gazette, then the Gazette International Networking Institute, and today Post-Polio Health International, which runs the International Ventilator Users Network.

Laurie led a national letter-writing campaign for attendant-care legislation in 1959. It failed nationally but succeeded in California. In her own account, attendant care “later cleared the path for the independent living movement, for attendant care is the linchpin of independence.” She confronted directly the assumption that ventilator users belonged in nursing homes: “I react violently to the suggestion… They do not need to be buried alive in a nursing home.”

Ed Roberts and Berkeley

Ed Roberts (1939–1995) contracted polio at fourteen, slept in an iron lung, and used glossopharyngeal breathing, sometimes called frog breathing, during the day. Admitted to UC Berkeley in 1962 over the administration’s objection, he insisted as a condition of moving into Cowell Hospital that his wing be treated as dormitory space, not a medical facility. That was a direct assertion of control against the default that a ventilator user belongs under medical authority.

The severely disabled students who followed him named themselves the Rolling Quads, launched the Physically Disabled Students Program, and in 1972 founded the first Center for Independent Living.

The two stories connect: Laurie featured Roberts in the Spring 1965 Toomeyville Jr. Gazette, a documented link between the polio survivor network and the emerging Berkeley movement.

Survivors Identified Post-Polio Syndrome First

From 1979, Laurie collected survivor reports of new fatigue, weakness, and pain. She convened the first international post-polio conference in Chicago in 1981 and co-edited the Handbook on the Late Effects of Poliomyelitis in 1984. This was patient-led research: survivors identified the syndrome before much of medicine accepted it.

What the Machine Changed

Before the first clinical use of the Drinker respirator in 1928, a person whose respiratory muscles were paralyzed by polio, diphtheria, botulism, or barbiturate poisoning usually died within hours or days. There was no way across the acute respiratory-failure window.

The population this page concerns did not exist before the technology, because most such people did not survive.

Philip Drinker and Louis Agassiz Shaw, with James Wilson credited in several accounts, developed the tank respirator at the Harvard School of Public Health. The first clinical use was on 12 October 1928, on an eight-year-old girl at Boston Children’s Hospital. She revived within about a minute. She died five days later of heart failure. Popular retellings usually stop at the revival.

Sourcing on life before the iron lung is genuinely thin from a first-person disability perspective, for a structural reason: the people most affected rarely survived to leave accounts. That gap is worth naming rather than filling with speculation.

Who Could Get One

Machines were scarce and expensive. A Drinker unit cost somewhere between about $2,000 and $3,600 depending on the source, which is on the order of $35,000 to $40,000 in today’s money, and a hospital needed many. Families “often could not afford to have a machine at their house and had to send sick children to hospitals far away,” per the CDC Museum. Rural families were disadvantaged by distance.

In 1931 John Haven Emerson produced a quieter, lighter machine for about $1,000. When Drinker and Harvard sued for patent infringement, Emerson won in 1935 and Drinker’s patents were declared invalid. Emerson argued both that the elements were not novel and that life-saving technology should be freely available to all.

The Color Line

Franklin Roosevelt’s Georgia Warm Springs Foundation, founded in 1927, admitted only white patients. Chief Surgeon Charles Irwin defended this directly: “We cannot take colored people for this reason,” the stated rationale being that Warm Springs maintained no segregated wards.

A prevailing pseudo-scientific claim that Black people were less susceptible to polio was used to justify neglect. The low reported case counts that supposedly proved it were distorted by underdiagnosis and underreporting.

After sustained pressure from Black activists and clinicians, the National Foundation for Infantile Paralysis announced its largest single grant to date in May 1939, $161,350, to establish an infantile paralysis center at the John A. Andrew Memorial Hospital on the Tuskegee Institute campus. It opened in January 1941 and operated until 1975, staffed by Black physicians, nurses, and therapists. It had about 36 beds and limited outpatient capacity, and could help only a fraction of those who sought care.

This center is a separate undertaking from the U.S. Public Health Service syphilis study at Tuskegee, but the two are more entangled than “same campus” suggests: the syphilis study also ran through the same hospital. Scholars note that Black scientists at Tuskegee, including Russell Brown and James Henderson, later built the cell-culture capacity essential to testing the Salk vaccine.

Wilma Rudolph and her mother made weekly bus trips of about fifty miles from Clarksville to Meharry Medical College in Nashville for two years, because Clarksville offered little care to Black residents.

The anchor scholarly source for this section is Naomi Rogers, “Race and the Politics of Polio: Warm Springs, Tuskegee, and the March of Dimes,” American Journal of Public Health 97(5), 2007, pages 784 to 795.

Who Decided

Control lay with physicians, hospitals, and the charities that owned the machines and paid for care. The March of Dimes funded chapters, respiratory centers, attendant care, and equipment. When donations fell after the vaccine, it stopped paying for attendants and closed the respiratory centers, stranding long-term users.

For acute users the iron lung was straightforwardly life-saving and time-limited; most spent days or weeks and weaned off. For those with permanent respiratory paralysis it was inescapable in a literal sense, and the surrounding institutional arrangements were often not chosen.

Weaning was a clinical decision made by staff, and it could be coercive. Paul Alexander described being forced by hospital staff to try breathing outside the lung until he passed out, which left him wary of health care professionals for years afterward.

Children were quarantined away from their families for months, with parents sometimes able to visit only through a window.

The Charity Frame

The March of Dimes pioneered mass small-donor philanthropy and, per PBS’s American Experience, by 1954 was “the nation’s leading health charity, capturing nearly half of all charitable donations to those causes,” taking in roughly $66.9 million that year. PBS also notes that with about 100,000 cases a year, polio was a smaller public health threat than tuberculosis, heart disease, cancer, cerebral palsy, or muscular dystrophy. Its fundraising dominance was a triumph of narrative, not of relative caseload.

The engine of that narrative was the poster child. Donald Anderson, of Prineville, Oregon, was the first, in 1946, photographed before and after treatment. Disabled writers have long criticized the model as producing pity and spectacle, and as demanding that disabled people perform gratitude. A first-person account published by Post-Polio Health International captures the child’s-eye view: “I was so embarrassed… I was always being chosen for publicity shoots… not that I had anything to say about it!”

Roosevelt’s own concealment belongs here too. Hugh Gregory Gallagher, himself a polio survivor, called it a deliberate cover-up in FDR’s Splendid Deception (1985): the press agreed not to photograph him in his wheelchair, and the Secret Service confiscated film. Historians dispute how complete the concealment was, with James Tobin arguing the public largely knew he was disabled. Activists later criticized the FDR Memorial’s initial refusal to depict his wheelchair. Gallagher wrote of that decision: “The denial continues.”

Obsolete While People Were Still Using It

The iron lung was allowed to become obsolete while living people still depended on it to breathe.

Emerson production ran from the 1930s into the 1970s. Positive-pressure ventilation and the vaccine ended the market. Manufacturers stopped making the machines and, critically, stopped supporting parts. Health insurance stopped covering repairs on equipment classified as obsolete.

What replaced manufacturer support was mutual aid. Paul Alexander described hunting for machines to cannibalize: “I’ve found them in barns. I found them in garages. I’ve found them in junk shops.” When his lung began failing in 2015, a friend posted a video appeal for a machinist. Mechanical engineer Brady Richards answered, refurbished a replacement, and became, in Alexander’s words, his “mechanical savior.” Richards named the core problem plainly: “The biggest challenge really was the lack of parts… nobody’s got them, so we have to make them ourselves.”

Martha Lillard had to find a used iron lung in the 1990s and depended on mechanics’ modifications for decades afterward.

The crux is this: obsolescence was declared by manufacturers and payers, not by the users, whose bodies had adapted over decades to negative-pressure breathing. Some users preferred it. Alexander’s summary of his own machine was “Give me electricity and I’m OK.”

The Last Users

In 2013, Post-Polio Health International estimated six to eight iron lung users in the United States. By 2017 its executive director said he knew of none for certain, though the journalist Jennings Brown then documented three.

Paul Alexander (1946–2024), of Dallas, contracted polio in 1952 at age six and spent about seventy-two years using an iron lung. Guinness recognized him for the longest time as an iron lung patient, recorded as seventy-one years. He earned a law degree from UT Austin, practiced as an attorney in family law and bankruptcy, wrote Three Minutes for a Dog: My Life in an Iron Lung (2020) using a mouth-stick, and built a following on TikTok. He was briefly hospitalized with COVID-19 in February 2024 and died on 11 March 2024; a cause of death was not established. On vaccination he said: “Now, my worst thought is that polio’s come back… I don’t even want to think about it.”

Martha Lillard (1948–2026), of Shawnee, Oklahoma, contracted polio in 1953 at age five and died on 26 June 2026 at seventy-eight. Her death certificate listed chronic pulmonary failure and post-polio syndrome; her sister attributed her decline to long COVID. She was described after Alexander’s death as the last known iron lung user in the United States, a characterization that comes from her family rather than from any registry, and one worth stating as “last known.” She described a power-outage entrapment as “like being buried alive,” and also said of the machine: “It felt good to breathe.”

Some coverage after her death claimed she died because her iron lung had become too old to repair. That framing does not appear in the wire reporting or the Oklahoma public radio coverage, which describe historical equipment troubles rather than a fatal failure. It fits the abandonment story a little too neatly, and it is not supported.

Mona Randolph (1936–2019), of Kansas City, contracted polio at twenty in 1956. She went about twenty years without ventilation before a post-polio relapse returned her to the lung, eventually six nights a week. She called it “my necessary, trusted, mechanical friend” and advocated for independent living for people with significant disabilities.

The Same Logic, Now

The principle that payers and manufacturers rather than users decide when life-sustaining equipment is worth maintaining did not retire with the iron lung.

In March and April 2020, disability rights organizations filed complaints with the HHS Office for Civil Rights against crisis-standards-of-care plans in Washington, Alabama, Kansas, Tennessee, Pennsylvania, Utah, and New York. Alabama’s plan had allowed denying ventilators to people with “severe or profound mental retardation,” “moderate to severe dementia,” and severe traumatic brain injury. Utah’s guidelines disqualified people with advanced neuromuscular disease, dementia, cystic fibrosis, and other conditions requiring daily assistance.

OCR resolutions followed through 2020 and into January 2021. One win matters directly to long-term ventilator users. In its resolutions with Tennessee and Utah, OCR secured language stating that hospitals “should not re-allocate personal ventilators brought by a patient to an acute care facility to continue pre-existing personal use,” so that long-term ventilator users “will be protected from having a ventilator they take with them into a hospital setting taken from them to be given to someone else.”

That protection is real and it was won by disabled organizers. It is also negotiated resolution language applying to specific states’ crisis standards, not a nationwide regulation binding every hospital. New York’s guidelines had expressly permitted taking ventilators from ongoing community users who sought hospital care, which is the harm Ari Ne’eman wrote about in the New York Times on 23 March 2020 under the headline “Disabled in the Coronavirus Crisis: ‘I Will Not Apologize for My Needs.’”

Today’s equivalent fight is over durable medical equipment coverage. Medicare covers home ventilators as continuing monthly rentals under a category that never transfers ownership to the user. Coverage rules, competitive-bidding rounds, and adherence criteria determine whether suppliers will stock and service the equipment disabled people breathe with. These figures and rules change often; check the current CMS rule rather than relying on any summary, including this one.

Polio Today

As of July 2026, wild poliovirus type 1 remains endemic only in Afghanistan and Pakistan. The World Health Organization’s Emergency Committee revised its targets in March 2026, aiming to interrupt endemic WPV1 transmission in 2026 and stop circulating vaccine-derived type 2 outbreaks by 2028, with certification of eradication no longer carrying a public date.

Case counts move; take them from the Global Polio Eradication Initiative’s “Polio This Week” rather than from Emergency Committee statements, which freeze counts at the meeting date.

Hundreds of thousands of polio survivors are alive in the United States. Estimates vary widely and depend heavily on which survey year is used and whether mortality since then is accounted for, so treat any single figure with caution. Many now live with post-polio syndrome, some using modern home ventilators.

The eradication story, while epidemiologically real, tends to erase living survivors. That is what “WE’RE STILL HERE!” is answering.

Organizations

Post-Polio Health International — survivor-founded; runs the International Ventilator Users Network. Publishes in Spanish, among other languages. Own voices
Post-Polio Litaff, A.C. (APPLAC) — Mexico, survivor-led, Spanish-language. Listed in Post-Polio Health International’s directory; its own site was not reachable as of July 2026, so no link is given here. Own voices Global South
Independent Living Institute — archive including material on Ed Roberts and the movement’s origins. Own voices

Where the Record Is Thin

Two gaps are worth naming rather than papering over.

First-person accounts from Latino and Spanish-speaking iron lung users are strikingly absent from the available record. Notably, the Texas polio-treatment record points toward integration rather than segregation: the Gonzales facility and several Texas hospitals admitted Black, white, and Latino patients. But no named first-person account of a Latino iron lung user was located, and no mid-century study quantifying access among U.S. Latinos appears to exist. That is a gap in the record, not evidence that such experiences did not happen.

Accounts from the poorest users, and from those who never left institutions, are similarly sparse. The people best positioned to describe lifelong institutional confinement are the least represented in what was written down.

Contribute to This Page

If you are a polio survivor, a ventilator user, or someone who cared for or repaired these machines, your account would strengthen this page. We are especially seeking first-person accounts from Latino and Spanish-speaking survivors, and from people who lived in institutions, since both are thin in the written record. See How to Contribute.

You may copy, reprint, translate, and adapt this page — CC BY-SA 4.0: credit us and keep your version open. How to reuse this.